Basecamp vs Smartsheet
A source-aware comparison of pricing, documented capabilities and workflow fit.
Short answer
- Price: not directly comparable — Basecamp is free tier available, Smartsheet is from $9/user/mo billed annually.
- How to start: Basecamp is free tier available, Smartsheet is from $9/user/mo billed annually.
- Where they differ: on what we checked they match — both offer public api, mobile app and sso (saml).
These lines are generated from the pricing we track, not from a paid placement. How we score tools.
What Basecamp is
What Basecamp isBasecamp organises projects around message boards, to-dos, schedules and chat, with a flat-fee pricing option instead of per-seat billing. The flat fee is the point: cost stops tracking headcount, which changes the maths for larger teams. In return you accept its opinionated structure, since there are no custom workflows, boards or automation rules to bend it into another shape.
What Smartsheet is
What Smartsheet isSmartsheet manages work in a spreadsheet-like grid with automations, dependencies and reporting layered on. The grid is deliberate: teams that already run projects in spreadsheets can move across without learning a new mental model, then gain Gantt views, approval workflows and cross-sheet reporting they could not build in a spreadsheet. It suits operational and portfolio work more than software development, where board-based tools fit the rhythm better.
Side by side
| Basecamp | Smartsheet | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Project Management | Project Management |
| How to start | Free tiernot a monthly price | $9/user/moverified |
| Public API | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile app | Yes | Yes |
| Open source / self-hostable | No | No |
| SSO (SAML) | Yes | Yes |
| Visit | Basecamp ↗ | Smartsheet ↗ |
Some links on this page earn us a commission if you sign up. It never changes a price you pay, a verdict we publish, or the order tools appear in.
What Basecamp is built to do
- Project-scoped tools
- Gives each project its own to-dos, message board, docs and schedule.
- Flat-fee option
- Offers a plan priced per company rather than per seat.
- Hill charts
- Reports progress by where work sits between unknown and done.
What Smartsheet is built to do
- Grid, Gantt and card views
- The same data shown as a sheet, a timeline or a board without duplicating it.
- Cross-sheet reporting
- Roll many project sheets into one portfolio view for reporting upward.
- Automated workflows
- Approval chains, reminders and status updates triggered by field changes.
- Forms
- Collect structured requests from people who never open the sheet itself.
Choose Basecamp if
- Teams that hate per-seat billing — every paid tier is a flat price with no per-user fee
- Small projects that fit the free plan: 1 project, 1 GB, up to 5 users
- Growing teams: Studio and above include unlimited users at no extra cost
Skip Basecamp if
- You need more than one project without paying — the free plan allows exactly one
- You want a cheap per-seat entry for two people; flat pricing starts at $25/mo regardless of headcount
- You need deep agile tooling; Basecamp is deliberately simple
Choose Smartsheet if
- Teams that think in spreadsheets but need automation, forms and dashboards on top
- Small groups: Pro starts at $9/member/month billed annually
- Trying it fully first — 30 days with no card
Skip Smartsheet if
- You need unlimited automations or timeline view; those start at Business, $19/member/month annual
- You want a free tier; Smartsheet has none, only a trial
- You are an existing customer hoping to move to Pro — the vendor lists Pro as available to new customers only
Evidence and freshness
Where a claim on this page comes from a vendor page, it is linked here.
Basecamp: pros & cons
- Flat pricing regardless of headcount
- Deliberately simple and calm
- Good for client-facing project work
- Too simple for complex dependencies
- No native Gantt or resource planning
- Opinionated structure resists customisation
Smartsheet: pros & cons
- Familiar to anyone comfortable in spreadsheets
- Handles dependencies and resource views
- Strong automation and forms
- Interface is dense
- Per-user pricing with feature gates
- Spreadsheet metaphor breaks on complex work
Our verdict on Basecamp
Refreshing if your team drowns in tooling. Engineering teams with dependencies will find it thin.
Our verdict on Smartsheet
The easiest migration path off spreadsheets. Teams that never liked spreadsheets will not like this either.
Published plans, side by side
Every figure below was read from the vendor's own pricing page and is shown with the sentence it came from. Where a vendor publishes no plan prices, we say so rather than guess.
Basecamp
- Free$0/mo
Free $0 with 1 project, 1 GB storage, up to 5 users
- Freelancer$25/mo
Freelancer $25/mo, Studio $59/mo, Pro $99/mo
- Studio$59/mo
Freelancer $25/mo, Studio $59/mo, Pro $99/mo
- Pro$99/mo
Freelancer $25/mo, Studio $59/mo, Pro $99/mo
- Unlimited Edition$299/mo billed annually
Unlimited Edition $299/mo billed annually
Smartsheet
- Pro$9/user/mo billed annually
Pro from $9 per member/month billed annually
- Business$19/user/mo billed annually
Business from $19 per member/month billed annually
Basecamp vs Smartsheet: common questions
- Does Basecamp or Smartsheet have a free plan?
- Basecamp has a free tier with limits, while Smartsheet has no free plan listed.
- Which is cheaper once you start paying, Basecamp or Smartsheet?
- The two are not priced the same way: Basecamp's cheapest paid step is Freelancer at $25/mo, while Smartsheet's is Pro at $9/user/mo billed annually. One scales with headcount and the other does not, so the cheaper option depends entirely on team size.
- What is the difference between Basecamp and Smartsheet?
- On the criteria we check, on what we checked they match — both offer public api, mobile app and sso (saml). The table above lists every criterion side by side.