Caddy vs October CMS

What Caddy is

Caddy is a web server that obtains and renews TLS certificates automatically, with a configuration file most people can read.

What October CMS is

October CMS is a self-hosted PHP CMS and application platform built on Laravel. Its source is public, but the platform is licensed under October's EULA rather than a standard permissive open-source license: each production website needs a project license, with development and staging environments for that same website covered. New accounts receive one complimentary license with one year of updates; an expired perpetual license keeps running but loses Update Gateway access. Hosting, database, deployment, backups and plugin governance remain the operator's responsibility.

What October CMS is built to do

Laravel foundation

Uses Laravel 12, Composer dependencies and Artisan commands for development and operations.

Themes and plugins

Separates presentation and extensible application behavior into project-controlled packages.

Roles and permissions

Controls backend access with users, custom roles, permission inheritance and super-user boundaries.

Multisite management

Manages domain, locale, theme and content variations from one installation.

Choose Caddy if

• Anyone who wants a correctly configured HTTPS server without ceremony.

Choose October CMS if

• Custom content sites where Laravel-native development is an advantage
• Agencies that can standardize deployment, updates and plugin review across projects
• Multisite or multilingual builds after validating shared-installation and license boundaries

Skip October CMS if

• A fully managed SaaS CMS with vendor-operated backups and upgrades is required
• The organization requires an OSI-style permissive license without per-site production terms
• The team cannot maintain PHP, Composer dependencies, plugins, database migrations and recovery

Caddy: pros & cons

• HTTPS configured correctly by default
• Configuration is short and legible
• Single binary, easy to deploy
• Smaller community than nginx
• Fewer third-party guides
• Some advanced setups need plugins

October CMS: pros & cons

• Developer-oriented stack: Laravel, Composer, Artisan, Twig themes and plugins support code-first customization.
• Self-hosted ownership: Application code, configuration, content database and deployment environment stay under the operator's control.
• Editorial controls: Backend users, roles, permissions and multisite content support governed authoring workflows.
• Flexible deployment: Composer/SSH and an official no-shell Deploy plugin cover different hosting environments.
• Production licensing: Public source does not remove the per-website license and EULA requirements.
• Updates depend on renewal: The site keeps running after expiry, but gateway updates and Marketplace access require an active license.
• Self-hosted operations: PHP, database, web server, secrets, patches, backups and recovery are the customer's responsibility.
• Extension risk: Marketplace or custom plugins add separate maintenance, compatibility, security and license surfaces.